Motorcycle Cruiser Homepage Motorcycle Cruiser
Get Adobe Flash player

Little Big V-Twins: Harley-Davidson Fat Boy, Kawasaki Vulcan 1600 Classic, Suzuki Marauder 1600 and Victory Kingpin Motorcycle Comparison Test

Somewhere between the 1700cc-and-up mega bikes and the 1300cc-and-under swarm is group of V-twin cruiser motorcycles that, for many riders, is just right. We picked four of our favorites for "The Almost-Big V-Twins Face-Off." Harley-Davidson Fat Boy versus
Lbt Xl 2004 Group Ride Rear View
Photography by Kevin Wing... 
   
  read full caption
Lbt Xl 2004 Group Ride Rear View
Photography by Kevin Wing.
2004 Harley Davidson Fat Boy Side Right View
The Fat Boy's unique disc... 
   
  read full caption
2004 Harley Davidson Fat Boy Side Right View
The Fat Boy's unique disc wheels can cause some side-wind issues. Our test unit had an accessory headlight and other goodies.
  • Huge accessory selection from huge number of companies
  • Comfy
  • Good cornering clearance for a big cruiser

  • There's one on every corner
  • Very pricey
  • Unimpressive brakes

  • Anything to make it look differnt than the thousands of other Fat Boys out there

    2004 Kawasaki Vulcan 1600 Classic Side Right View
    The Kawasaki includes features... 
       
      read full caption
    2004 Kawasaki Vulcan 1600 Classic Side Right View
    The Kawasaki includes features such as a helmet lock, adjustable shock damping and a tool kit under the locking side cover. That ugly black license-plate support needs a chrome replacement
  • Nicely sorted suspension
  • Solid braking performance
  • Best passenger seat

  • Unimpressive power output
  • Limited cornering clearance
  • Clutch issues
  • Unfinished visual details

  • New seat (unless you are short)
  • New clutch plates
  • Narrow the handlebar

    2004 Victory Kingpin Side Right View
    Visually similar to the successful... 
       
      read full caption
    2004 Victory Kingpin Side Right View
    Visually similar to the successful Vegas, Victory's Kingpin has slightly less edgy style and more creature comforts.
  • Impressive class-dominating power
  • Great finish quality and distinctive style

  • Virtually no detail features
  • Drags early and hard

  • Add accessory tach
  • Add accessory HID headlight

    2004 Suzuki Marauder Side Right View
    You can tell it's a Suzuki... 
       
      read full caption
    2004 Suzuki Marauder Side Right View
    You can tell it's a Suzuki Marauder by the tailsection. The similar Kawasaki Mean Streak has a conventional fender; otherwise the core bike is obvious. The engine is mostly the same as the 1600 Classic's.
  • Most comfortable motorcycle (for the rider) in this foursome
  • Best brakes here—powerful, controllable and adjustable
  • Most detail features in this group
  • Tachometer is standard

  • Tiny seat pad insults passenger
  • Brand identity crisis

  • Install a passenger saddle

    2004 Suzuki Marauder Ride Left View
    Friendly steering manners... 
       
      read full caption
    2004 Suzuki Marauder Ride Left View
    Friendly steering manners and superior suspension make the Marauder comfortable and fun to ride in corners, even though lean angle is slightly limited.
    2004 Victory Kingpin Ride Right View
    The Victory's pretty lines... 
       
      read full caption
    2004 Victory Kingpin Ride Right View
    The Victory's pretty lines always started conversations. It also got a lot of attention when leaned over since it drags easily and hard, startling small animals and passers-by.
    2004 Kawasaki Vulcan 1600 Classic Ride Left View
    The 1600 Fi lacks in cornering... 
       
      read full caption
    2004 Kawasaki Vulcan 1600 Classic Ride Left View
    The 1600 Fi lacks in cornering clearance, though it handles solidly thanks to well-engineered suspension and strong, linear brakes.
    2004 Harley Davidson Fat Boy Ride Left View
    Although "Fat Boy" doesn't... 
       
      read full caption
    2004 Harley Davidson Fat Boy Ride Left View
    Although "Fat Boy" doesn't sound like the best choice for twisty roads, the Harley's ground clearance allows it to lean over farther than the other three.
    2004 Harley Davidson Fat Boy Engine View
    Harley's 1450cc big twin has... 
       
      read full caption
    2004 Harley Davidson Fat Boy Engine View
    Harley's 1450cc big twin has become the little guy in this class, but its air-cooled two-valve design still makes respectable power—making it quicker than the Kawasaki 1600 Classic.
    2004 Kawasaki Vulcan 1600 Classic Engine View
    Introduced last year, the... 
       
      read full caption
    2004 Kawasaki Vulcan 1600 Classic Engine View
    Introduced last year, the Kawasaki 1600 engine is an 82cc expansion of the 1500 with extensive changes throughout. Details like the unsightly horn grate on us.
    2004 Suzuki Marauder Engine View
    This engine differs from the... 
       
      read full caption
    2004 Suzuki Marauder Engine View
    This engine differs from the Classic's left with 37mm instead of 33mm intake valves, bigger intake ports, 40mm instead of 36mm injector throats and new cam profiles.
    2004 Victory Kingpin Engine View
    Victory's engine is the power... 
       
      read full caption
    2004 Victory Kingpin Engine View
    Victory's engine is the power champion of the almost-big twins. It makes both the most horsepower and the most torque.
    2004 Harley Davidson Fat Boy Front Suspension View
    Harley's suspension is slightly... 
       
      read full caption
    2004 Harley Davidson Fat Boy Front Suspension View
    Harley's suspension is slightly harsh but adequately damped.
    2004 Suzuki Marauder Rear Suspension View
    Like the Kawasaki, the Suzuki's... 
       
      read full caption
    2004 Suzuki Marauder Rear Suspension View
    Like the Kawasaki, the Suzuki's rear suspension offers adjustable damping via a thumbwheel.
    2004 Victory Kingpin Front Suspension View
    Victory gets functional fat... 
       
      read full caption
    2004 Victory Kingpin Front Suspension View
    Victory gets functional fat fork legs by using inverted legs.
    2004 Kawasaki Vulcan 1600 Classic Rear Suspension View
    Like the Suzuki, the Kawasaki... 
       
      read full caption
    2004 Kawasaki Vulcan 1600 Classic Rear Suspension View
    Like the Suzuki, the Kawasaki uses shaft final drive, which is heavier and creates more drivetrain lash than a belt. Some see it as more reliable, though.
    Lbt Xrp Eb Lg
    Lbt Xrp Af Lg
    Lbt Xrp Ac Lg
    2004 Harley Davidson Fat Boy Side View
    2004 Kawasaki Vulcan 1600 Classic Side View
    2004 Suzuki Marauder Side View
    2004 Victory Kingpin Side View

  • BMW M3 Research
    BMW M3 Review in-depth reviews on the new BMW M3, featuring test drives, comparisons, options, features and more. The V8 standard engine in the M3 gives you 414 horsepower with an estimated 17 mpg. It is available in the following bodystyles: Coupes, Convertibles, Sedans. The Dodge Charger and the Chrysler 300 are other vehicles that might interest you.

    Latest Articles

     
    Harley-Davidson Touring Motorcycles to Offer Optional Garmin GPS
    According a release by Garmin International, the leading producer of Global Positioning Satellite... more
     
    2006 Harley-Davidson FLHX Street Glide Road Trip / 2007 Street Glide First Look
    Read about this cross country trip on a 2007 Harley Davidson Street Glide... more
     
    Harley Extends Warranties for Certain Military Personnel
    Under a program announced by Harley-Davidson on Memorial Day, military personnel involved in... more

    More Related Content